Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Why We're Skeptical Of LeBron James

Would you rather lose the fast pace, hitting, or heads?

Craig Button of NHL on the Fly has got very upset over the recent injuries of Dallas Stars' players after collisions with Douglas Murray.  Anybody who's been paying attention knows that head injuries have become a big fad in the media as of late, but what shocks me is that now the discussion is not about illegal hits to the head, it's about player safety.  These hits from Douglas Murray are perfectly legal and Craig Button is trying to crucify him.  Button actually used the term "undue force."  What the fuck is that?  Players get injured just running into Douglas Murray.  How can you possibly chastise a defenseman for playing the puck and knocking down the player?  What's funny about this is that everybody is searching for an answer to stop the head injuries without taking hitting out of the game and the conversation goes something like this:

"Since the rules have been changed to speed up the game by eliminating hooking, holding, and interference, the number of reported concussions has gone way up.  How can we change the rules further in order to stop players from injuring each other?  Hmmmm.  Let's think about it.  Hmmmm.  There doesn't seem to be any way around it without taking hitting out of the game or penalizing all head contact."

Either it has occurred to no one to change the rules back to slow the play down or no one is willing to publicly consider it.  Is the NHL simply too arrogant to admit that it might have been wrong to speed the game up to dangerous levels?  Or is the faster pace is simply more important to them than player safety and/or hitting in the game?

Star-divide

The thing is:  I like the fast pace.  Everybody likes the fast pace.  Not once since the rule changes have I heard anybody lament the elimination of the two-line pass rule.  But I also like the physicality of the sport.  Everybody does.  If we liked slow, non-contact sports, we'd all be sitting around watching pre-season baseball right now, falling asleep in armchairs with half-finished bottles of beer resting on our guts.

The last option seems to be to penalize all head contact, which would inevitably lead to a lot more bullshit penalties for accidental head contact or diving, which is a penalty that exists already, so we know the referees are terrible at calling it.

So I put it to you.  Would you rather see the speed of the game diminished, the hitting eliminated, or head injuries?

Poll
Which would you rather see eliminated from the NHL?
Speed
2 votes
Hitting
1 votes
Heads
13 votes

16 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 16 comments  |  2 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Battle of California

Sharks Gameday: Thornton's Eleven

Dec 2011 by Megalodon - 71 comments

Sharks of Anarchy

Aug 2011 by Megalodon - 65 comments

Sharks Gameday: Xerxes I

Apr 2011 by Megalodon - 33 comments

Comments

Display:

penalize all head contact determined by the ref to be blatent headhunted give them the discretion…yea..the ref may get some calls wrong…but Im betting with the 2 refs theyll get most calls correct…were not fuckin robots…do not fear human element…otherwise have no refs..and let toronoto make all penalty calls from there war room..how stupid is that

Im not a guy who blames refs for shit..teams have to fight thru occasional bad calls..a couple come back your way eventually…work on your PK

Meg bows down to my fantasy greatness
"Thank you very much fans and let’s go for the next game together!"
Go Ducks!
www.battleofcali.com

by SPADE-IN-VICTORHELL on Mar 17, 2011 1:09 PM PDT reply actions  

I should start by saying this is a great fanpost. Vote, people!

Not once since the rule changes have I heard anybody lament the elimination of the two-line pass rule.

It’s been a while for me, but I’ve at least questioned its overall effectiveness on increased scoring.

It’s like the two-line pass. Sure the concept seems sexy—every once in a while you do get to see a cool long-bomb pass that leads to a great scoring chance. But what you might not notice as glaringly is the inherent cost of these occasional moments. For sixty minutes now both teams are defending against the long-bomb pass; a defender can’t support his team’s rush for fear of the cherry-picker. It’s a steady cost to weigh against an infrequent benefit. It would have been nice to have observed this rule change’s effect on scoring on its own, but unfortunately we have been stuck with a slew of simultaneous untested changes so it’s impossible to isolate what effect the two-line pass has on scoring.

I really wish this rule had been tested on its own — I’m very skeptical that it does increase scoring, as now there is a constant need to defend against two-line passes.

www.battleofcali.com

by Earl Sleek on Mar 17, 2011 1:10 PM PDT reply actions  

ya know I never thought of that…..shit…

Meg bows down to my fantasy greatness
"Thank you very much fans and let’s go for the next game together!"
Go Ducks!
www.battleofcali.com

by SPADE-IN-VICTORHELL on Mar 17, 2011 1:12 PM PDT up reply actions  

I think Scotty Bowman recently said in an article to get rid of the two line pass too. I’m not sure where that article is, but I remember reading it somewhere pretty recently.

by Wooster11 on Mar 18, 2011 7:07 AM PDT up reply actions  

I’m very skeptical that it does increase scoring

Granted that that was the stated purpose of the rule change, but I think you can discuss the question of whether or not is has made the game more exciting separately from that.

"Prepare your bladder for imminent release!" — Invader Zim

by DougX on Mar 18, 2011 2:48 PM PDT up reply actions  

I think it’s still fair to question whether it has in fact increased scoring. The league lies to us all the time — just because it’s what the rule was intended for doesn’t mean it actually works.

www.battleofcali.com

by Earl Sleek on Mar 18, 2011 3:39 PM PDT up reply actions  

I don’t know that it has led to an increase in scoring, but if the defense backs up more to defend the neutral zone, that spreads the team out a bit, leading to more open ice and faster breakouts. I think that is the kind of play that the NHL espouses and which may or may not directly contribute to the increase in devastating hits.

Frankly, I think the NHL likes devastating, spectacular hits because fans do, but there have been a ton of injuries and they’re coming under a lot of heat for it.

by meetyourmako on Mar 18, 2011 7:28 PM PDT up reply actions  

Off with their heads!

I was almost going down and then I didn’t go down and then it came and it was too late to get down.
Battle of California

by Megalodon on Mar 18, 2011 7:15 AM PDT reply actions  

True dat

It’s always a lot easier to find something when you know in advance what you’re supposed to be looking for, and this is a phenomenon that occurs frequently outside of sports.

"Prepare your bladder for imminent release!" — Invader Zim

by DougX on Mar 18, 2011 2:46 PM PDT up reply actions  

I chose the words “reported concussions” carefully to acknowledge that, but I don’t feel I’m in a position to speculate as to the actual number of concussions pre-lockout.

by meetyourmako on Mar 18, 2011 7:36 PM PDT up reply actions  

Remove fat players from the game. Overweight players like

Douglas Murray
Dustin Byfuglien
Kyle Wellwood
Drew Doughty

These guys have no business in the league.

by Scottyknow on Mar 21, 2011 5:55 PM PDT reply actions  

we could have separate heavyweight, middleweight, and lightweight leagues.

by meetyourmako on Mar 22, 2011 12:38 AM PDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Takes and trash talk from all sides of the NHL's most pathetic* rivalry

* Thanks, Kevin Lowe!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

0107001523_small
Hockey, Burrito or Sex?

Recent FanPosts

Small
Thank you Ryan Clowe
We_tried_icon_small
2012 Playoff Pool Update R1
Nangibbons_small
How Injuries Impacted the NHL's California Teams
We_tried_icon_small
2012 Stanley Cup Playoff Pool
Wdiamondbackrattlesnake_small
2011 Happy Holidays from the Sharks
Jumbo_small
Sharks fan coming down to a Kings game - advice??
Small
My Sharks rally video for the last 13 games & A prayer to the Hockey Gods
Wdiamondbackrattlesnake_small
What California thinks of the rest of America
Stanford_block_s_small
Logan Couture has moved on

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

5 years old and counting!


Managers

Ducksuicide2_small Earl Sleek

Tumblr_ly4ejnteyd1r2sm49o1_500_small RudyKelly

Marleau_awkward_mustache_small Mike Chen

Megalodon_small Megalodon

Editors

San2_small Cheechew

Shark_hat_small pj48

Small jamestobrien

Authors

0107001523_small SPADE-IN-VICTORHELL